Squat and Squabble

Conflicting viewpoints on topical subjects

  • Latest Posts
  • USA Politics
  • Other Stuff
  • Pop’s Pearls of Wisdom
  • Southpaw’s Ramblings
  • About Us

Fake Newspeople?

June 6, 2017 by Pops Leave a Comment

Regardless of a person’s political leanings or other demographic, most everyone has a particular news personality that they favor. People prefer certain journalists primarily because they trust them, and secondarily because those journalists are affable, engaging, or share other traits that comport with the personality of the news consumer.

But mostly, it is a relationship based on trust. People watch, or listen, or read news to get facts about other places, other events, and other people that they wouldn’t otherwise know. And whether the TV news consumer prefers one of the major networks, or a cable channel, or a streaming service, when someone desires news, they want and expect the truth. Consumers want actual news – reality, with real people, real events, and real places.

On the other side of news reality is entertainment fiction, and successful fiction is the story that blends the incredible with the credible in such a way as to become more believable.

One of the techniques that creators of fiction have successfully used to inject believable reality into an otherwise fictional story is to add a journalist into the storyline. Remember “Godzilla” when Raymond Burr was the American reporter broadcasting onsite from the destruction of Tokyo? Or the radio show “War of the Worlds” when the northeast U.S. went into an actual panic over a Martian invasion when the radio show was presented as an actual live newscast? In the quest for ever more believability in fiction, it has become common for movies and TV shows to incorporate actual news personalities in reporting the fictional events as they transpire in the made-up storyline.

So what’s the problem with that?

Day after day, we watch our journalists of preference provide us the facts of the day. We trust them. Whether it is Wolf Blitzer, Rachel Maddow, Sean Hannity, Chris Matthews, or any other major news presenter makes no difference. We watch them because we believe them.

So what happens to that credibility factor when we see our own trusted news journalists doing gigs as themselves reporting on a fictional work? An excellent example is the Netflix series “House of Cards.” This is a storyline of high political fiction and intrigue, and in most episodes, the imaginary events of the day are portrayed by real broadcast media journalists reporting fictional news, as themselves, in support of the imaginary story.

When you watch and hear someone you trust, playing a role as themselves on a fictional show but telling you something that you know is utterly untrue with the same demeanor and sincerity that they have when they report “real” news, it gives one pause. If your journalist can be so believable reporting fictional news, how do you know that they are not also acting when they report the “real” news to you night after night?

What if your parish priest performed a role in a movie as a priest who molested children? What if the judge in your civil rights case was a part-time actor who portrayed a racist jurist from Alabama?  What if your banker portrayed a TV banker with a gambling addiction who embezzled all of the bank’s money?  As you watched them perform, wouldn’t your own comfort meter register a swing, at least a little?

Quite simply, persons whose professions are based on relationships of trust should not engage in acts that convincingly display their ability to be untrustworthy.

Don’t show me how credible you can be when you are pretending to tell me the truth – it gives me reason to doubt you all the time.

Tweet

Filed Under: Other Stuff

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Log In

Please log into the site.

Search

RSS Fox News

  • DOJ won't charge Sen. Burr over pre-pandemic stock trades
    Sen. Richard Burr on Tuesday announced that a Department of Justice probe into stock trades he made before the coronavirus pandemic ravaged financial markets was now closed, indicating the end of investigations into transactions made by four senators ahead of the pandemic.
  • Trump frees former aides from ethics pledge, lobbying ban
    President Donald Trump, in one of his final acts of office, released current and former members of his administration from the terms of their ethics pledge, which included a five-year ban on lobbying their former agencies.
  • Pro-Trump super PAC transforming into anti-Biden group
    A super PAC that supported President Trump’s 2020 re-election bid is changing its name – and its mission.
  • Two GOP House freshmen beat the odds, land coveted committee spots
    Two swing-district Republican House freshmen scored coveted spots on the House Appropriations Committee in a rare feat for newly elected members.
  • Trump and Bannon's rocky road to a pardon
    President Trump early Wednesday issued former White House senior adviser Steve Bannon a pardon. 
  • Biden to sign 17 executive actions, orders to reverse Trump policies, restore Obama-era programs on first day
    President-elect Joe Biden will sign 17 executive actions and orders in the first hours of his presidency on Wednesday.
  • Kwame Kilpatrick's road to Trump commutation of corruption sentence
    Former Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick was among 70 people who had their prison sentences commuted by President Trump early Wednesday, just hours before the end of the president's term in office.
  • Biden's inauguration: Everything you need to know
    The United States on Wednesday will once again transfer power from one president to another, as it has done since 1797 when George Washington left office to be replaced by the second American president, John Adams. 

RSS CNN International

  • President-elect Biden will be sworn in as the 46th president of the United States today. Harris will make history as the first female US vice president.
    • Watch CNN live: The inauguration of Joe Biden
  • Watch CNN's special coverage: The inauguration of Joe Biden
  • Germany tightens restrictions as death toll rises
  • THE BIDEN INAUGURATION: A NEW DAY IN AMERICA
  • Nigeria's Burna Boy featured on US inauguration playlist
    Nigerian artist Burna Boy will feature on the official playlist for the inauguration of President-elect Joe Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris.
  • Biden prepares to conjure hope for a grieving nation
  • Annika Sorenstam defends accepting Presidential Medal of Freedom a day after Capitol riot
    Golfing great Annika Sorenstam has defended her decision to accept the Presidential Medal of Freedom a day after rioters stormed the US Capitol.
  • US accuses China of 'genocide' of Uyghurs and other minority groups
    The Trump administration has determined that China has committed genocide and crimes against humanity against Uyghur Muslims and ethnic and religious minority groups who live in Xinjiang, a remote region in China's far west.

Archives

  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017

Copyright © 2021 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in