Squat and Squabble

Conflicting viewpoints on topical subjects

  • Latest Posts
  • USA Politics
  • Other Stuff
  • Pop’s Pearls of Wisdom
  • Southpaw’s Ramblings
  • About Us

Erasing the Past

August 16, 2017 by Pops 2 Comments

Statue Pulling – the New American Pastime?

Yesterday, on Tucker Carlson’s show, he made an observation that was so good that I had to quote it in full.

“One thing President Trump said Tuesday deserves more attention than it will likely get.
On Monday a mob tore down a civil war soldier’s memorial in Durham, North Carolina. Police stood idly by and liberals across the country applauded it. Which statues are next, the president asked today, George Washington, Thomas Jefferson?
It’s not a joke. Suddenly it’s a serious question.
Thomas Jefferson indisputably was a great man. He was the author of the Declaration of Independence. Founder of the University of Virginia and maybe, most importantly, the greatest thinker in American political history.
All of us live in his shadow. Unfortunately, however, Jefferson was also a slave holder. That’s real. It’s a moral taint. We ought to remember it.
But to the fanatics on the left it means that Jefferson must be purged from public memory forever. The demands are already coming that we do that.
In 2015, the students at the University of Missouri demanded the removal of a Jefferson statue. Two years ago, on CNN, anchor Ashleigh Banfield suggested the Jefferson Memorial in Washington might have to go. Needless to say there is literally no limit when you start thinking like this.
Last year, hundreds of activists in New York demanded the statue of Theodore Roosevelt at the American National History Museum be dismantled. They argued that Roosevelt was a racist.
That’s the standard. Nobody is safe.
Watch out Abraham Lincoln. You’re next.
Now, to be clear, as if it’s necessary, slavery is evil. If you believe in the rights of the individual, it’s actually hard to think of anything worse than slavery.
But let’s be honest. Up until 150 years ago when a group of brave Americans fought and died to finally put an end to it, slavery was the rule, rather than the exception around the world. And had been for thousands of years, sadly.
Plato owned saves, so did Mohammed — peace be upon him.
Many African tribes held slaves and sold them. The Aztecs did, too. Before he liberated Latin America, Simon Bolivar owned slaves.
Slave-holding was so common among the North American Indians that the Cherokee brought their slaves with them on the Trail of Tears. And it wasn’t something they learned from European settlers.
Indians were holding and trading slaves when Christopher Columbus arrived. And by the way, he owned slaves, too.
None of this is a defense of the atrocity of human bondage. And it is an atrocity.
The point however is that if we are going to judge the past by the standards of the present. If we are going to reduce a person’s life to the single worst thing he ever participated in, we had better be prepared for the consequences of that. And here’s why: Forty one of the 56 men who signed the Declaration of Independence held slaves.
James Madison, the father of the Constitution, had a plantation full of slaves.
George Mason, the father of the Bill of Rights, also owned slaves, unfortunately. But does that make what they wrote illegitimate?
If these men were simply racist villains, and that’s all they were, then the society they created is as evil as they were. There is no reason to respect its traditions or uphold its laws.
The First Amendment, for example, the right to speak freely — For hundreds of years Americans have revered it. Now, the left dismisses it as the work of white supremacist slave holders. It is worthless, they tell us. It must go.
It is now routine to hear liberals claim that hate speech, whatever that is, isn’t protected by the First Amendment. Though of course the whole point of the First Amendment is to protect speech that offends people.
It’s a statement of shocking ignorance and yet it is now common.
CNN’s Chris Cuomo said it. He is supposedly a lawyer.
At Pomona College in California, students there are claiming that free speech is “a tool appropriated by hegemonic institutions.”
Whatever that means. They say the right of free expression should only apply to certain racial groups.
But that’s not racist because as you know there is no racism on the left.
They are just sincere people concerned about hate.
There is actually a vitally important debate going on in the country right now. And it’s not about statues or even the alt-left antifa, it’s about American institutions and whether they are worth preserving.
Radicals on the left want to tear it all down as they did the statue in Durham Tuesday.
Equality under the law.
Protections for the individual against the mob.
The absolute right to say and believe anything you choose.
Those will be gone. Replaced by something darker and more rigidly conformist.
Is that a country you want to live in?
If it’s not, now is the time to speak up. elites are refusing to. They are too afraid.”

If you want to see the video, here it is:  http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2017/08/16/tucker-carlson-if-want-to-erase-past-must-prepare-for-consequences.html

Tweet

Filed Under: USA Politics

Comments

  1. Southpaw says

    August 16, 2017 at 7:29 pm

    I definitely understand the argument being made, but I think that a statue of Robert E. Lee greatly varies from those of other prominent figures in American History. Robert E. Lee was a Confederate General. He was the leader of those who sought to subjugate African Americans for the sake of economic gain. Almost any educator out there (who isn’t wearing a white hood) will say that he was on the wrong side of history. He did not help us build our nation. He sought to divide it and was ultimately stopped by the Union. Yes, there are many great Americans with checkered pasts, but in this case, we should not defend the monuments of those who sought to divide this country. We may not be able to hold individuals of the past to our current moral standards, but we should not praise those who wholeheartedly fought in favor of an immoral cause.

    Log in to Reply
    • Pops says

      August 17, 2017 at 3:48 pm

      Southpaw lacks information about Robert E. Lee. Lee was a brilliant military tactician who graduated with honors from West Point. He had served the US Army for 32 years when the South seceded. When Virginia declared its secession from the Union in April 1861, Lee chose to follow his home state, despite his desire for the country to remain intact and an offer of a senior Union command. Lee had inherited slaves from his mother, and freed them in 1862, years before the North freed their own. Yes, he should have a statue in the park.

      Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Log In

Please log into the site.

Search

RSS Fox News

  • President Biden to visit Mississippi after tornadoes ravage state, leaving 25 dead
    President Biden will visit Mississippi on Friday, almost one week after devastating tornadoes hit portions of the state leaving 25 people dead.
  • Biden 'strongly opposes' resolution ending COVID-19 national emergency, but won't veto it after Senate vote
    President Biden will not veto a resolution ending the COVID-19 national emergency that the U.S. Senate passed on a 68-23 vote on Wednesday, A White House spokesperson said.
  • First on Fox: McCarthy hauls in a record $35 million in fundraising since becoming House Speaker
    House Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s off to a fast start in building a formidable war chest as he aims to expand the Republican majority in the chamber in next year’s elections.
  • Nashville school shooting: Republican congressmen demand AG Garland launch hate crime investigation
    Two Republican congressmen sent a letter to Attorney General Merrick Garland demanding that the DOJ open a hate crime investigation into the Nashville private Christian School shooting.
  • Ohio lawmaker moves to force vote on constitutional amendment rules
    GOP Ohio state Rep. Susan Manchester pulled a discharge position that, if successful, would allow a proposal to make amending the state constitution harder to bypass via normal processes.
  • Minneapolis City Council to discuss potential settlement in major Floyd lawsuit
    The Minneapolis City Council will hold a special meeting to discuss a potential settlement in a suit by the Minnesota Department of Human Rights over George Floyd's police-involved death.
  • DOJ charges two more people for attacks against Florida pro-life pregnancy center
    The Justice Department charged two more people on Wednesday for carrying out a targeted attack on a pro-life pregnancy center in Winter Haven, Florida
  • Mel King, Boston civil rights figurehead and former mayoral candidate, dead at 94
    Mel King, a prominent civil rights figurehead in Boston credited with much of the city's progress on integration in the 1970s and 1980s, died Tuesday. He was 94.

RSS CNN International

  • Wagner chief admits battle for Bakhmut has 'battered' private military group
  • India welcomes its first newborn cheetahs in over 7 decades
    More than 70 years after cheetahs were declared officially extinct in India, the country is now home to four newborn cheetahs, India's Environment Minister announced Wednesday.
  • Beijing warns of 'severe impact' on US-China relations as Taiwan's leader lands in New York
    Taiwan's relationship with the United States has "never been closer," its President Tsai Ing-wen said after arriving in New York City Wednesday, as Beijing warned her visit could lead to "serious confrontation" between China and the US.
  • FIFA strips Indonesia of U-20 World Cup after calls for Israel ban
    Soccer's world governing body FIFA has stripped Indonesia of its right to host the Under-20 Men's World Cup later this year after an Indonesian official objected to the participation of Israel.
  • 'Companies are holding out': Global IPO market slump endures
    A slowdown in global initial public offerings continued in the first quarter of 2023 and is likely to endure in the coming months, as companies wait out the effects of volatile stock markets, higher interest rates and inflation, and uncertainty around the banking crisis.
  • Extraordinary video shows officers racing to confront Nashville shooter
  • 'Calculated' attack: New details on Nashville shooter
    A college art instructor who taught the Nashville school shooter told CNN the attacker once had an outburst in class and appeared to be "suffering" in social media posts over the past year.
  • Russia's nuclear blackmail is a spectacular success for Putin

Archives

  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in